News flash: Pentagon hires futurists to figure out future

After I saw this item on BoingBoing, I couldn’t hold back:

The Pentagon issued a secret report to Bush warning him that catastrophic climate changes in the next 15 years are a bigger threat than terrorism, and will lead to massive riots and nuclear war.

Actually, this is bogus, so I sent Mark Frauenfelder a note (which I’ve made HTML-friendly here):

Mark, I saw your item about the Office of Net Assessment report today. A few things become clear if you read the original Fortune article in which the report was mentioned.
First, the Pentagon is a building, so it didn’t issue the report itself. The report you cite was commissioned by Department of Defense’s Office of Net Assessment (ONA). Andy Marshall is the director of ONA; see this article for background.
Marshall’s job, which he’s had since about 1973, is to think of radical scenarios and assess which ones the Department of Defense should be preparing for. This has a long tradition, dating back at least to the Navy’s “Plan Orange” for fighting Japan in the 30s. . In the more immediate past, this forward thinking has led to a renewed focus on ballistic missile defense and a variety of interesting ARPA projects (including the recent “Metabolic Dominance” project, which personally I think is very cool).
Radical scenarios, and potential consequences thereof, is exactly what they got with this report: ONA hired Peter Schwartz (who is famous for helping Royal Dutch Shell prepare for an oil market where prices *dropped* instead of monotonically increasing) and his Global Business Network firm (see here for more on GBN). GBN’s mission was to prepare a menu of *possibilities*, which, if you read the Fortune story, is exactly what they did.
I haven’t read the report, but some of the scenarios that Forbes cites as possibilities from the report (water wars between Canada joining the US in an alliance, à la Fred Pohl’s “Foodies” in JEM) are familiar to futurists and sci-fi readers. The more interesting question is whether Marshall’s influence, coupled with the clear scientific evidence that there are tipping points at which dramatic climate changes happen *quickly*, will prompt any changes in US policy. (for one example, see this NOAA page).
Unfortunately, the interesting aspects of this project have been buried under an avalanche of bogosity, like the Guardian article that breathlessly labeled the *speculative* “secret report” as an official Pentagon *prediction*. It’s not.

Update: the report itself is available from Greenpeace. Interesting reading.

1 Comment

Filed under Smackdown!

Medicine time

So, all five of us went to the doctor yesterday. Actually, Arlene went to our new family doctor on my behalf, this after I woke him up at 0730 on the day he returned from a long trip to New Zealand– oops! Here’s the verdict:

  • Paul & Arlene: upper respiratory tract junk. Allegra-D for congestion, Combivent to open the lungs, Flonase for the sinuses, and antibiotics for the actual germs. Of course, each one of these has to be taken on a different schedule. I’m going to need one of those little boxes like Aunt B. (However, I must say that Allegra-D works great— one pill == twelve hours of easy breathing.)
  • Thomas: two ear infections. The doc said his eardrums were the color of his red Spiderman shirt. This, of course, is after a four-day course of vitamin Z, so now he’s on something stronger. Remarkably, he hasn’t complained of pain, and he’s been well-behaved, but he’s got a profound hearing loss, so we knew something was wrong.
  • Matt: one ear infection. This was obvious given the volume of gunk that was draining from his left ear, so now he’s got the same antibiotic as Thomas.
  • David: probably has what the rest of us have, but he’s still at a very early stage, so no medicine for him.

After one day of medicine, I feel about 2000% percent better; let’s hope that keeps up. More importantly, Matt slept through the night last night for the first time in a week, which is good for everybody.

Comments Off on Medicine time

Filed under Musings

Make your own 404 page

Ever wonder how to make your own custom “page not found” page appear? Dave Taylor has a tutorial that gives some examples, some of which are pretty funny.

Comments Off on Make your own 404 page

Filed under General Tech Stuff

Rain Fall (Eisler)

If you’ve never heard of Barry Eisler, and you like thrillers, you’re missing out. His first book, Rain Fall is the story of John Rain, a half-American/half-Japanese assassin living in Tokyo. The plot details, although interesting, are secondary to Eisler’s outstanding scene descriptions, characterizations, and dialogue. His descriptions of Tokyo by night are superbly evocative, right up there with James Lee Burke’s descriptions of bayou thunderstorms. Rain is a complicated character; it was initially tempting to write him off as a cardboard killer-with-a-heart-of-gold, but as the novel develops, his character is more fully revealed. Highly recommended; if you’re not convinced, Eisler’s web site has the first chapter available– a move which I heartily applaud.

Comments Off on Rain Fall (Eisler)

Filed under Reviews

Exchange and Software Assurance

[meta-note: there’s no real security tie-in, but I’ve decided to post links to the weekly column I write for Windows & .NET Magazine. That at least guarantees fresh content here every Monday!]

This week’s column focuses on Microsoft’s Software Assurance (SA) licensing, how it works, and why Microsoft is (currently) making the Exchange Intelligent Message Filter available only to SA subscribers.

Late last week, Microsoft made an announcement that has many Exchange Server administrators fuming. The new Exchange Intelligent Message Filter, expected to ship later this year, will be available only to customers enrolled in Microsoft’s Software Assurance (SA) program. On the face of it, this decision might seem shortsighted on Microsoft’s part; after all, wouldn’t the company want to sell its products to anyone who wants to buy them? However, from a long-term strategic point, the decision makes good sense for customers and for Microsoft.

Comments Off on Exchange and Software Assurance

Filed under General Stuff, Musings

Sig Weber’s blog

Sigfried Weber (Exchange MVP, developer par excellence, and gracious host) finally has his own blog. For his most recent trick, he’s made SharePoint emit properly formed RSS. Drop by his site and say hello!

Comments Off on Sig Weber’s blog

Filed under Friends & Family

Sig Weber’s blog

Sigfried Weber (Exchange MVP, developer par excellence, and gracious host) finally has his own blog. For his most recent trick, he’s made SharePoint emit properly formed RSS. Drop by his site and say hello!

Comments Off on Sig Weber’s blog

Filed under General Stuff, Musings

Important new security update released

There’s a major security vulnerability that affects practically every retail outlet in the US. See the description here.

Comments Off on Important new security update released

Filed under Security

A little housekeeping

In honor of the March 17 release date for Secure Messaging with Exchange Server 2003, I’ve done a little housecleaning. The Exchange 2000 version is still available, so I’ve tried to update the links in the right column so that they correctly point to the appropriate book. I’ll be posting sample chapters as soon as I can get MS Press to send them to me; ditto the TOC and index.

Comments Off on A little housekeeping

Filed under General Stuff, Musings

Test post with Ecto

I’m testing Ecto (née Kung-Log) to see how it works. So far, it’s quite slick.

Comments Off on Test post with Ecto

Filed under General Tech Stuff

It must be winter

Arlene is sick. Thomas is sick. Matthew is sick. I don’t feel well, although it’s sort of a proto-sick state rather than full-blown winter ick. Thus, instead of teaching 300 people about Windows security in Redmond (like I was supposed to be today through Saturday), I’m hiding in my basement, popping Sudafed like Rush Limbaugh and trying valiantly to cut through the cloud of fuzz that seems to have enveloped me.

Comments Off on It must be winter

Filed under Musings

Sleep tight

According to the US Census Bureau, more Americans are injured by beds each year (466,464) than by skateboards, all-terrain vehicles, swimming pools, televisions, and power saws combined (a total of 389,128). Sleep well!

Comments Off on Sleep tight

Filed under Musings

Pakistani nuclear surety links

Over at Instapundit, Glenn points to this story and wonders if it’s true. I couldn’t find anything recent, but a little Googling turned up some interesting tidbits.
My layman’s understanding of the Non-Proliferation Treaty is that command-and-control assistance (e.g. systems for surveilling, communicating with, or controlling nuclear forces or weapons) would be prohibited, but surety assistance (e.g. making sure that weapons can’t be detonated accidentally or without proper authorization) wouldn’t necessarily be banned. In fact, it would seem like a good thing to give surety assistance to countries, like Pakistan, where the political conditions may make it more likely that someone will attempt to detonate a weapon without authorization. It’s not clear if the Pakistanis want help with C-and-C or surety, and what (if any) help the US is offering.
So, on with the links. First, this NBC story from 2/8 is cited in the Telegraph story. NBC quotes unnamed sources as saying that the Pakistani warheads are more secure than India’s and that India has almost a 2-1 warhead advantage (interesting, if true, since conventional wisdom says the opposite). However, the story goes on to claim that Pakistani weapons are insecure because of political instability (probably true) and that the US has “contingency teams” ready to secure the weapons; neither claim is attributed.
Another related report I can find (citing Sy Hersh in the New York Times) is dated 12/7/01 in the Asia Times. Hersh’s original story claimed that an elite US military unit was training to sneak into Pakistan and steal or disable their weapons, if necessary, to prevent them from being used. (Of course, this report also says “Pakistan has kept its promise to the international community not to export, share, transfer or assist any country in nuclear technology”, so take it with a grain of salt.) More interestingly, the article claims that the US turned down Pakistan’s 2001 request for command-and-control upgrades, but it doesn’t cite a source.
Sean Gregory has a February 2001 report here that points out the challenge of building reliable command-and-control in countries where communications and power infrastructures are unreliable.
The Center for Nonproliferation Studies has a report that assesses Pakistani surety as good, outlining some specific scenarios and explaining what measures Pakistan has taken (or is assumed to have taken) to prevent them. The biggest measure they appear to have taken is to separate the fissile warhead cores from the warheads and delivery systems. This would be like taking the buckshot out of your shotgun shells and storing shells, shot, and shotgun in three separate locations; it makes it much more difficult for unauthorized parties to assemble the weapon components, since they have to compromise more than one site; however, it also increases the amount of time required to generate a complete weapon for strategic response.
There’s an interesting undated paper here that ends by saying “the safety and security measures are likely to remain primitive by Western standards”. Yikes. The safety measures built into the weapons themselves can be quite complex; this draft USAF document outlines some of the standards that apply. Steve Bellovin has a fascinating document here that describes some of these safety measures in more detail.

Comments Off on Pakistani nuclear surety links

Filed under Musings

Floral gift certificates

A friend of mine is selling 800-Flowers gift certificates for 65 cents on the dollar. How is this possible? He bought a ton of them during their end-of-the-year promotion, which gave 100 Delta frequent flyer miles for each $1 spent. He’s legit. Contact him at andymo99 AT aol DOT com if you’re interested.

Comments Off on Floral gift certificates

Filed under Friends & Family

With press like this…

Yow! TiVo got two stories on the front page of the Marketplace section in yesterday’s Wall Street Journal. Neither of them were exactly favorable, although they did spell “TiVo” correctly 🙂
The first, by Nick Wingfield and Jennifer Saranow, points out that (gasp) TiVo gathers viewing data. There’s a quote from Richard Smith (summary: TiVo is saying “you have to trust us”, duh), and a counterbalancing quote from TiVo’s chief privacy officer. The article points out that the satellite- and cable-based PVRs are capable of gathering this data, even though none of them currently do, and the closing paragraph summarizes my feelings exactly:

Some users, such as Jayne Spiegelman, 48 years old, say they’re willing to put up with some monitoring because of the benefits they get out of the technology. “If it starts invading my privacy,” the Atherton, Calif., technology executive says, “yeah I’ll have a problem with it. But right now, I’m so infatuated with the TiVo service itself.”

The other column is by Lee Gomes. Most longtime Mac users well remember his numerous (and wrong) “Apple is dying” columns from the early-to-late 90s, and this is pretty much in the same vein; he dismisses the filing as “somewhat cheeky” and doesn’t present any real technical detail on the merits of TiVo’s claim– understandably, I guess, since the suit is still in its early stages. The patents are interesting reading, though.

Comments Off on With press like this…

Filed under HDTV and Home Theater